I'm curious if anyone has advice on problems that could occur by leaving only urine waste in the waste tank. I haven't had a chance to dump it and its been about a month. We only used it 3 times and it is only urine. I used that chemical blue dye to contain smells every time i dump it. I added a gallon or 2 of water into the tank to keep it diluted. Will this help to keep the tank fresh and my Class c28 smelling fresh?
Weird questions of the month category!
We do it all the time, I add about 5 gallons of water (45 gal tank), then the chemicals. We can't use the blue chemicals that contain formaldehyde due to disposal problems but still don't run into any problems.
Same here. Don't use the blue dye. Hurts the environment, kills the good bacteria and limits where you can dump, especially in California.
I've done the same thing; dumped and cleaned tanks at sites with dump stations after camping, but for those one day trips with no dump sites, or boondocking, waited until the next camping trip (or stop at Flying J) or until the tanks become 2/3 to 3/4 full; whichever comes first. Haven't had any problems with odor or waste residue to date. I'm using an enzyme based product compatible with my city's sewer system so that I could dump at home when absolutely necessary. I just make sure that there's plenty of liquid in the tank so that solids will fully dissolve.
*This Message was edited on 14-Mar-02 06:05 PM by LLeopold*
Between RVs at this point
but I continue to tent camp!
Well, if no one can use the " blue chemicals" then why is it made and sold by the same company that makes the toilet? Or are we talking about a different blue stuff? I make reference to Campa Chem and Thetford.
We belong to a private club with our own park and had to put in a sand filter sewer system. The engineers told us the formaldehyde would kill the bacteria it needs to work and cost $1,000 to clean out and restart the system. Does the same thing to any septic system. Some parks have two dump stations, one for the good stuff (TST, enzyme's etc) and another one for the blue Thetford type stuff.
No problem at all leaving it that long or longer. But you can do yourself and your environment a favor by skipping the "blue stuff".
20 years ago we didn't want to kill our septic system, so researched holding tank solutions. Settled on Mr. Clean. Environmentally friendly, works well and is inexpensive. During hot weather I add 1/2 bottle to about 5 gallons of water after flushing tanks. Winter I use 1/3 bottle.
Saw a TV ad last night for 4 new 'flavors' of Mr. Clean, in additon to the pine scent. I'll check labels to make sure only the fragrance changed.
Our septic is still working good, with no odor. Also no odor from the RV and sometimes it will have waste in the tanks for a couple of months.
Once saw a sign on the break room fridge of a company I was visiting. It said "If it can walk, then set it free!" Folks said the group did a much better job of throwing out the old stuff in the fridge after the sign was added.
I wouldn't try to set any holding tank records if I were you.
mombum: The folks continue to make that stuff because its cheap to make, people continue to buy it, make a profit in it, and there are no laws against it (it's just getting harder to find dumping stations that permit one to dump using it).
I guess the best way to describe the "aldahyde" stuff is that formaldahyde and the other "aldahydes" are used to preserve organic materials. Why would I want to preserve my waste products? I want them broken down to their component parts as rapidly as possible. Enzyme and bacteria-based products accomplish this. Since the smell comes from bacteria breaking down the waste and their waste is methane gas, the enzyme/bacteria-based products accelerate this process and minimize the gas produced rather than slow it down, as the "aldahyde" products do (which is why they need the additional chemicals to overcome the smell).
Various folks have their favorite brands, and they are all good and compatible with the environment based on what I've seen. What drove me to my particular brand was I wanted something compatible with my community's waste management system and was able to find its RV counterpart. This way I could dump to my city sewer system if necessary without worrying about the city coming down on me.
*This Message was edited on 15-Mar-02 11:39 AM by LLeopold*