RV.Net Open Roads Forum: Tow Vehicles: Modifying TV for heavier Fiver

RV Blog

  |  

RV Sales

  |  

Campgrounds

  |  

RV Parks

  |  

RV Club

  |  

RV Buyers Guide

  |  

Roadside Assistance

  |  

Extended Service Plan

  |  

RV Travel Assistance

  |  

RV Credit Card

  |  

RV Loans

Open Roads Forum Already a member? Login here.   If not, Register Today!  |  Help

Newest  |  Active  |  Popular  |  RVing FAQ Forum Rules  |  Forum Help and Support  |  Contact

Search:   Advanced Search

Search only in Tow Vehicles

Open Roads Forum  >  Tow Vehicles

 > Modifying TV for heavier Fiver

This Topic Is Closed  |  Print Topic  |  Post New Topic  | 
Page of 10  
Prev  |  Next
Sponsored By:
soling2003

Federal Way, WA

Senior Member

Joined: 09/09/2010

View Profile


Offline
Posted: 02/24/12 09:04pm Link  |  Print  |  Notify Moderator

OP-
Ok, I'm one that kind of did your mods. I added the airbags and larger tires with more weight carrying capacity. I added the airbags to level the truck when hooked up to the 5th wheel, and larger tire cause I didn't like the dinky and poor performing stock Continentals.
The results were good on handling. I was new to 5th wheels, so didn't rwalize how heavy the pin was. My 2010 F250 LB 4x4 CC diesel only had a 1720lb payload rating. After weighing it once, I found out I was 600 lbs over the RAWR and almost 1000 lbs over the GCWR. It towed it fine, but I didn't like being so far over. The F350 SRW truck in 2010 had the same GCWR, but more RAWR. So because of the combined weight, I had to go to a dually. The difference was lost night and day. Much better ride with that much weight! I did end up with a 2011 though.

Be careull, everyone states the 250/350 differences, but in some years the axles were in fact different, 2010 was one of them I found out. Some years they were the same.

In closing, yes you can o it, it will probably work, but the right truck designed for the load is better.


DW and 2 dogs
2011 Ford F350 Dually LB 4x4 CC 6.7 diesel
2007 Grand Junction 35TMS
Peterson 37(just sold) T-37 R/C Sailboat at home

Skip N Barb Team

Dickinson, Texas

Senior Member

Joined: 09/11/2007

View Profile



Posted: 02/24/12 09:06pm Link  |  Print  |  Notify Moderator

NC Hauler

So, you're telling me that the airbags don't assist to give a higher payload.

That simply doesn't make sence. I have five leaf springs on my truck. I load my fiver and it lowers about two inches. If I add the 1 leaf to be the same as a 1 ton truck, it settles 1 inch.

I add the bags, it lowers 2 inches, I add air to bring it back to level, taking stress off the springs, and putting more on the axles. The additional weight has been added to the axles, wheels, and tires.

The axle is the same as the 1 ton, so if I replace the wheels with Chevy 1 ton srw, and add the 265 tires with a 3420# rating, and stay within my total towing capacity, staying within the payload of a 1 ton, what am I doing wrong?

As others stated adding airbags to a 1/2 ton will give more payload. I don't think their staying within the axle, wheels, and tire ratings, realizing they were trying to be a bit funny.

My rear weight now is 3300#'s

I'm looking at a new fiver of @2100# pin weight dry.

After loading, I'll figure about 2600 - 2700#'s.

265 tires give me 6840#'s max

Less 3300#' = 3540#'s

I figure adding the bags, wheels, and tires will give me a little cushion. I'll be over the total allowed weight of my truck, under the total allowed rear weight, and within my total towing weight, and saving a bunch of $$$'s.

There's been over a 1000 hits on this thread, but no one has really come forward with the answer to my question.

I hope it's not because they're afaid to be pounded by the "WEIGHT POLICE"

I do appreciate the input here. It's a great forum!!!

Skip

NC Hauler

Asheville NC

Senior Member

Joined: 05/20/2005

View Profile



Good Sam RV Club Member

Online
Posted: 02/25/12 03:35am Link  |  Print  |  Notify Moderator

Skip N Barb Team wrote:

NC Hauler

So, you're telling me that the airbags don't assist to give a higher payload.

That simply doesn't make sence. I have five leaf springs on my truck. I load my fiver and it lowers about two inches. If I add the 1 leaf to be the same as a 1 ton truck, it settles 1 inch.

I add the bags, it lowers 2 inches, I add air to bring it back to level, taking stress off the springs, and putting more on the axles. The additional weight has been added to the axles, wheels, and tires.

The axle is the same as the 1 ton, so if I replace the wheels with Chevy 1 ton srw, and add the 265 tires with a 3420# rating, and stay within my total towing capacity, staying within the payload of a 1 ton, what am I doing wrong?

As others stated adding airbags to a 1/2 ton will give more payload. I don't think their staying within the axle, wheels, and tire ratings, realizing they were trying to be a bit funny.

My rear weight now is 3300#'s

I'm looking at a new fiver of @2100# pin weight dry.

After loading, I'll figure about 2600 - 2700#'s.

265 tires give me 6840#'s max

Less 3300#' = 3540#'s

I figure adding the bags, wheels, and tires will give me a little cushion. I'll be over the total allowed weight of my truck, under the total allowed rear weight, and within my total towing weight, and saving a bunch of $$$'s.

There's been over a 1000 hits on this thread, but no one has really come forward with the answer to my question.

I hope it's not because they're afaid to be pounded by the "WEIGHT POLICE"

I do appreciate the input here. It's a great forum!!!

Skip


These airbags, as rick so aptly stated are not your semi tractor type air bags.....THOSE airbags are part of the trucks OEM suspension...The airbags we ADD to our trucks are not part of the trucks OEM suspension, they level, how come no one want's to believe what the actual designers and manufacturers of the Air bags state about their product? I mean, if they actually CLAIMED that these bags added GVWR to one's truck, they could sell them for $500 dollars a set or more...

I'm about explained out....it's there for the reading and research on the airbags that we buy to put on our trucks...Talk to an Automotive design engineer, believe we even have an at least one ex one on this forum.

You said it yourself, you put air in the bags and it levels the load, may even give you a more stable and smoother ride, they DO exert that extra weight on the axle and tires, the leaf springs are part of the suspension...they are now carrying that same weight, the air in the bags pushed down on the axle and up on the bed thus raising it.

Those that are adding airbags to 1/2 ton trucks are not adding one ounce of payload carrying capacity to their truck....again, they pushed the bed of the truck up and are still putting the same amount of weight pushing down on the axle, springs and tires, they've leveled that trucks load, it may tow smoother, it may be a little more stable loaded, but, if they were over the trucks GVWR or even its RAWR and added airbags to compensate for that, they have misunderstood how aftermarket airbags we add to our truck work and are still over the limits as would be a 3/4 ton, 1 ton SRW and 1 ton DWR truck would be that added air bags to it to get more GVWR or RAWR..


....hey add two sets of air bags and one could probably tow a 20,000# Carriage with a 3/4 ton truck...I mean that's the logic we're seeing here...Funny how they rate most of these bags at 5,000# each and yet know one is "assuming" that they should now be able to raise their GVWR by that amount...I could go from a a GVWR on my truck that now has 12,200# and with two 5,000# airbags, go to at least a GVWR of 17,200#...on wait, I just exceeded my axle rating by over 7,000# or more...why didn't the math work out???

Air bags are designed and manufactured for the leveling of a load and to help smooth out a loaded vehicles ride.

....oh, I caught the dig on the weight police thing.. no one is really worried about being "pounded" by the weight police...The shoe is on the other foot now...when someone, who just states the obvious, as in this airbag question or recommends a 3/4 ton truck over a 1/2 ton when opinions are asked, or a dually for a job....it's usually the majority who jump on those who have, like me, been jumped on by the weight police way back in, I just listened, did the research and found out in my case, I was wrong and they were right, again, "in my case"....I don't believe one needs a Freightliner to tow a pop-up...funny analogy and illogical at best, but some go a long way to justify towing over one's truck towing limits...

I'm explained out...you can win the discussion, don't do the research, ignore the facts that you say no one has stated on these forums, believe what you want to believe...I've done the undersize truck towing too much weight, I've done the airbag thing, I finally swallowed my pride and had to admit I was wrong in MY trucks application with the 5er I chose (years back)...to me, it was an expensive lesson learned over the years....but, what do I know? To each his own...People call me the weight police, make fun of a lot of post, but it is what it is and it's nothing a little research won't prove it out on...Live and Learn....some do, most don't...


Jim & Kathy
2013 Dodge 3500DRW Longhorn 4X4/CC/LB/Aisin tranny/4:10/Cummins: 385HP/850TQ
06 HR Presidential Suite 37RLQ/ 4 slide/ dual pane windows/Winegard SK3005 Satellite/Splendide XC2100 W/D
Boxers;Buddy& Sheba II
USAF 71-75 Nam Vet

WVU fan

Engineer9860

Eagle Scout dad

Senior Member

Joined: 08/10/2003

View Profile



Posted: 02/25/12 04:53am Link  |  Print  |  Notify Moderator

NC Hauler wrote:

Skip N Barb Team wrote:

NC Hauler

So, you're telling me that the airbags don't assist to give a higher payload.

That simply doesn't make sence. I have five leaf springs on my truck. I load my fiver and it lowers about two inches. If I add the 1 leaf to be the same as a 1 ton truck, it settles 1 inch.

I add the bags, it lowers 2 inches, I add air to bring it back to level, taking stress off the springs, and putting more on the axles. The additional weight has been added to the axles, wheels, and tires.

The axle is the same as the 1 ton, so if I replace the wheels with Chevy 1 ton srw, and add the 265 tires with a 3420# rating, and stay within my total towing capacity, staying within the payload of a 1 ton, what am I doing wrong?

As others stated adding airbags to a 1/2 ton will give more payload. I don't think their staying within the axle, wheels, and tire ratings, realizing they were trying to be a bit funny.

My rear weight now is 3300#'s

I'm looking at a new fiver of @2100# pin weight dry.

After loading, I'll figure about 2600 - 2700#'s.

265 tires give me 6840#'s max

Less 3300#' = 3540#'s

I figure adding the bags, wheels, and tires will give me a little cushion. I'll be over the total allowed weight of my truck, under the total allowed rear weight, and within my total towing weight, and saving a bunch of $$$'s.

There's been over a 1000 hits on this thread, but no one has really come forward with the answer to my question.

I hope it's not because they're afaid to be pounded by the "WEIGHT POLICE"

I do appreciate the input here. It's a great forum!!!

Skip


These airbags, as rick so aptly stated are not your semi tractor type air bags.....THOSE airbags are part of the trucks OEM suspension...The airbags we ADD to our trucks are not part of the trucks OEM suspension, they level, how come no one want's to believe what the actual designers and manufacturers of the Air bags state about their product? I mean, if they actually CLAIMED that these bags added GVWR to one's truck, they could sell them for $500 dollars a set or more...

I'm about explained out....it's there for the reading and research on the airbags that we buy to put on our trucks...Talk to an Automotive design engineer, believe we even have an at least one ex one on this forum.

You said it yourself, you put air in the bags and it levels the load, may even give you a more stable and smoother ride, they DO exert that extra weight on the axle and tires, the leaf springs are part of the suspension...they are now carrying that same weight, the air in the bags pushed down on the axle and up on the bed thus raising it.

Those that are adding airbags to 1/2 ton trucks are not adding one ounce of payload carrying capacity to their truck....again, they pushed the bed of the truck up and are still putting the same amount of weight pushing down on the axle, springs and tires, they've leveled that trucks load, it may tow smoother, it may be a little more stable loaded, but, if they were over the trucks GVWR or even its RAWR and added airbags to compensate for that, they have misunderstood how aftermarket airbags we add to our truck work and are still over the limits as would be a 3/4 ton, 1 ton SRW and 1 ton DWR truck would be that added air bags to it to get more GVWR or RAWR..


....hey add two sets of air bags and one could probably tow a 20,000# Carriage with a 3/4 ton truck...I mean that's the logic we're seeing here...Funny how they rate most of these bags at 5,000# each and yet know one is "assuming" that they should now be able to raise their GVWR by that amount...I could go from a a GVWR on my truck that now has 12,200# and with two 5,000# airbags, go to at least a GVWR of 17,200#...on wait, I just exceeded my axle rating by over 7,000# or more...why didn't the math work out???

Air bags are designed and manufactured for the leveling of a load and to help smooth out a loaded vehicles ride.

....oh, I caught the dig on the weight police thing.. no one is really worried about being "pounded" by the weight police...The shoe is on the other foot now...when someone, who just states the obvious, as in this airbag question or recommends a 3/4 ton truck over a 1/2 ton when opinions are asked, or a dually for a job....it's usually the majority who jump on those who have, like me, been jumped on by the weight police way back in, I just listened, did the research and found out in my case, I was wrong and they were right, again, "in my case"....I don't believe one needs a Freightliner to tow a pop-up...funny analogy and illogical at best, but some go a long way to justify towing over one's truck towing limits...

I'm explained out...you can win the discussion, don't do the research, ignore the facts that you say no one has stated on these forums, believe what you want to believe...I've done the undersize truck towing too much weight, I've done the airbag thing, I finally swallowed my pride and had to admit I was wrong in MY trucks application with the 5er I chose (years back)...to me, it was an expensive lesson learned over the years....but, what do I know? To each his own...People call me the weight police, make fun of a lot of post, but it is what it is and it's nothing a little research won't prove it out on...Live and Learn....some do, most don't...


Your explanation is only partially correct. If properly installed, and inflated, the airbags take weight off of the truck's OE springs in proportion to how much air is in the airbags. Your explanation about the axles/tires remains correct.


In Memoriam: Liberty Belle


Engineer9860

Eagle Scout dad

Senior Member

Joined: 08/10/2003

View Profile



Posted: 02/25/12 04:57am Link  |  Print  |  Notify Moderator

MadMav wrote:

Nobody has yet to prove the GM axles are the same from 2500HD to 3500HD.

Mav


I have, in multiple threads just like this one when it has came up in the past. Don't have the links right now, but the info is out there.

The rear axle in the Chevy/GMC 2500HD with the the Duramax, or the 8.1L engine is the same as the 3500HD SRW. The 3500DRW obviously uses a different axle than do the SRW models.

Engineer9860

Eagle Scout dad

Senior Member

Joined: 08/10/2003

View Profile



Posted: 02/25/12 05:00am Link  |  Print  |  Notify Moderator

soling2003 wrote:

OP-
Ok, I'm one that kind of did your mods. I added the airbags and larger tires with more weight carrying capacity. I added the airbags to level the truck when hooked up to the 5th wheel, and larger tire cause I didn't like the dinky and poor performing stock Continentals.
The results were good on handling. I was new to 5th wheels, so didn't rwalize how heavy the pin was. My 2010 F250 LB 4x4 CC diesel only had a 1720lb payload rating. After weighing it once, I found out I was 600 lbs over the RAWR and almost 1000 lbs over the GCWR. It towed it fine, but I didn't like being so far over. The F350 SRW truck in 2010 had the same GCWR, but more RAWR. So because of the combined weight, I had to go to a dually. The difference was lost night and day. Much better ride with that much weight! I did end up with a 2011 though.

Be careull, everyone states the 250/350 differences, but in some years the axles were in fact different, 2010 was one of them I found out. Some years they were the same.

In closing, yes you can o it, it will probably work, but the right truck designed for the load is better.


The OP is discussing GM trucks. The axle comparison of the Ford brand is not relevant in this particular case.

Engineer9860

Eagle Scout dad

Senior Member

Joined: 08/10/2003

View Profile



Posted: 02/25/12 05:16am Link  |  Print  |  Notify Moderator

rick83864 wrote:

If I understand pickup trucks air bags right, they are static meaning the bags don't change when going down the road. A big rig air ride suspension is dynamic meaning it releases air when needed and then the bag is replenished with air hundreds of time per minute.
Coil or leaf springs are also dynamic which is why I would suggest adding a spring before a pickup truck air bag.
I think some people confuse a big rig air ride suspension with our available air bags for pickups.
Now wouldn't that be nice, a true air ride suspension on a pickup. It would most likely add $10k to window sticker. There is actually a couple of guys here that have done the conversion, member Me2 maybe?
I believe that is why any of our air bag companies clearly state they won't add a weight rating but rather just for leveling a load.


Rick, in your explanation, coil, and leaf springs are static just like the supplemental air bags in this case are, meaning they are not dynamically adjustable for a change in load. You can add air to supplemental air bags like Timbrens, while at rest, but not once the vehicle is moving down the road.

The primary air suspension on a OTR truck has an automatic leveling valve. No matter how much weight is on an 18-wheeler air suspension, the ride height will always be the same. As weight is added the pressure in the air bag is automatically increased to reflect this. As weight is removed so will the leveling valve remove air pressure to return the suspension to the design ride height.

The volume of air in an OTR truck's air bags will always be the same.

Drinkwater

Florida

Senior Member

Joined: 10/16/2008

View Profile



Good Sam RV Club Member

Offline
Posted: 02/25/12 06:06am Link  |  Print  |  Notify Moderator

This is right from the Silverado owners manual. It states that the fifth-wheel or gooseneck kingpin weight should be 15% to 25% of the trailer weight "up to 3000lbs" I would say that if he is under 3000lbs pin weight, and within his tire ratings of 6840 on the rear tires, and under the max trailer weight / vehicle weight, he should be OK. A 2700 lb pin weight on his truck should be just fine.




C-2500 Crew Cab Standard Box HD (2WD)*
Axle Ratio Maximum Trailer Weight GCWR**
6.0L V8 3.73 4.10
10,000 lbs (4 536 kg)
12,500 lbs (5 670 kg)
16,000 lbs (7 257 kg)
18,500 lbs (8 391 kg)
*Fifth-wheel or gooseneck kingpin weight should be 15 percent to 25 percent of trailer weight up to 3,000 lbs
(1 361 kg) maximum.
*Trailer rating limited to 13,000 lbs (5 897 kg) with weight distributing hitch.
**The Gross Combination Weight Rating (GCWR) is the total allowable weight of the completely loaded vehicle and
trailer including any passengers, cargo, equipment and conversions. The GCWR for your vehicle should not be
exceeded.


1 DW 1 DS 1 DMIL & 2 dogs
2008 Ford F450 King Ranch 4x4, w/4:88's
2008 Raptor 3612
Broke, but happy!

North Florida


gmcsmoke

Butler

Senior Member

Joined: 07/13/2008

View Profile



Good Sam RV Club Member

Offline
Posted: 02/25/12 06:10am Link  |  Print  |  Notify Moderator

Engineer9860 wrote:

soling2003 wrote:

OP-
Ok, I'm one that kind of did your mods. I added the airbags and larger tires with more weight carrying capacity. I added the airbags to level the truck when hooked up to the 5th wheel, and larger tire cause I didn't like the dinky and poor performing stock Continentals.
The results were good on handling. I was new to 5th wheels, so didn't rwalize how heavy the pin was. My 2010 F250 LB 4x4 CC diesel only had a 1720lb payload rating. After weighing it once, I found out I was 600 lbs over the RAWR and almost 1000 lbs over the GCWR. It towed it fine, but I didn't like being so far over. The F350 SRW truck in 2010 had the same GCWR, but more RAWR. So because of the combined weight, I had to go to a dually. The difference was lost night and day. Much better ride with that much weight! I did end up with a 2011 though.

Be careull, everyone states the 250/350 differences, but in some years the axles were in fact different, 2010 was one of them I found out. Some years they were the same.

In closing, yes you can o it, it will probably work, but the right truck designed for the load is better.


The OP is discussing GM trucks. The axle comparison of the Ford brand is not relevant in this particular case.



Huge pain to find this since AAM changed their website but attached is a PDF.

Go to page 34 (reference section and AAM lists the 11.5" for both 2500 and 3500 apps. This is for the diesel, gas gets a 10.5"


AAM axle guide

JIMNLIN

out here

Senior Member

Joined: 09/14/2003

View Profile



Posted: 02/25/12 07:23am Link  |  Print  |  Notify Moderator

rick83864 wrote:

JIMNLIN wrote:


The ticket part of the story in the clicky isn't credible as a leo can only write a overweight ticket on being over the vehicle axle/tires capacity or over the truck in question states registered weight GVW/GCW requirements (if any). There is no statutes written for quote: "for hauling the trailer with a tow vehicle that was not rated for the weights of the trailer".

Not so sure Jim


Section 24002(a) CVC prohibits a vehicle or combination of vehicles
which is in an unsafe condition or which is not safely loaded and which
presents an immediate safety hazard from operating on the highway. This
section provides officers the authority to stop a vehicle or combination
of vehicles that is, in the officer’s opinion, unsafe to operate on
the highway. This section could be used to prohibit a driver from
continuing until the unsafe condition is fixed.

I'm aware states have that type catch all type statute as well they should however the story line that says;
"for hauling the trailer with a tow vehicle that was not rated for the weights of the trailer"
and the OP constantly harping about the vehicle was overloaded, doesn't indicate this was the case.


"good judgment comes from experience, and a lot of that comes from bad judgment" ............ Will Rogers

'03 2500 QC Dodge/Cummins HO 3.73 6 speed manual Jacobs Westach
'97 Park Avanue 28' 5er 11200 gvwr two slides

This Topic Is Closed  |  Print Topic  |  Post New Topic  | 
Page of 10  
Prev  |  Next

Open Roads Forum  >  Tow Vehicles

 > Modifying TV for heavier Fiver
Search:   Advanced Search

Search only in Tow Vehicles


New posts No new posts
Closed, new posts Closed, no new posts
Moved, new posts Moved, no new posts

Adjust text size:

© 2013 RV.Net | Terms & Conditions | PRIVACY POLICY | YOUR PRIVACY RIGHTS